Beady Eye are good but they are not great, Oasis will still be remembered in 20 or 50 years time, Beady Eye are not even in the same league, Oasis was a musical giant that could sell millions while Beady Eye is a little fish in a big pond. The simple fact is Beady Eye are lacking the big anthems like wonderwall and Don't look back in anger that can unite the masses, songs that appeal to everyone from middle aged parents to casual fans and teenagers. Timing and music trends are also against Beady Eye, this decade is the hip hop generation, people under 30 don't have the same passion for rock music as previous generations did, most teenagers want to be like Eminem or Lady GaGa. Also Liam Gallagher is nearly 40, look at the music greats from history they all made their best music in their 20's from Elvis, John Lennon, Paul McCartney, Bob Dylan, David Bowie and Morrissey. I really want Beady Eye to be a success but realistically they will struggle to be a mid level type of band that can sell out small, medium size venues, good luck to Liam, you're gonna need it !!!!!! Or Liam could stop singing in this pub band and join a real rock band like Oasis !!!!!!!!